Site AI Auditsukūrė Internet Solutions

Soft 404 Finding: Missing Pages That Return 200 OK

2026 m. lapkričio 17 d.Skaitymo laikas: 7 min.SEO pagrindai
Soft 404 Finding: Missing Pages That Return 200 OK

Short answer: A soft 404 happens when a page that does not exist still answers with the status “200 OK”, as if it were a real page. During the first step of the check, Site AI Audit asks your server for an address that cannot exist. If the server answers 200 instead of 404, the audit reports a warning: “Missing pages return 200 OK instead of 404”. Search engines may then index empty or error pages as real content. The fix is to make the server return a genuine 404 status for pages that do not exist.

What a status code is

Every time a browser or a search engine asks your server for a page, the server answers with a three-digit status code before it sends anything else. 200 means “here it is”. 301 means “it has moved”. 404 means “there is nothing at this address”. Visitors do not see these numbers, but search engines rely on them. When a crawler receives a 404, it knows that the page is gone and drops it from its list. When it receives a 200, it believes the page exists and tries to read and index what the server sent.

A soft 404 is the mismatch between what the visitor sees and what the crawler is told. The visitor sees a message such as “Page not found”. The crawler receives a 200 status with that message as the page’s content. From the crawler’s point of view, your site has a page whose content is “Page not found”, and it may keep it.

How the audit tests for it

The audit does not hunt for broken links to find this problem. It uses a simple test during the first step of the run: it requests an address on your domain that should not exist, one made of random characters. A healthy server answers with 404. If the answer is 200, the server treats every address as valid, and the audit reports the finding. The explanation in the report says that search engines may index empty or error pages as real content, and the advice is to configure the server to return a 404 status for pages that do not exist.

This is different from the finding about broken internal links, where the crawler finds real links that lead to error pages. That is the topic of the guide on the broken internal links finding. The soft 404 check is about how your server behaves for any address at all.

Why it is a warning

The finding is rated a warning because it does not hurt every visitor immediately, but it quietly damages how search engines see the site. Consequences include:

The more pages a site has, the bigger the effect. For a small site it is a hygiene problem, and for a large shop or a blog with thousands of old addresses it can become a real drain. The article on soft 404s: how to spot and fix them covers the same issue from the Search Console side.

Common causes

How to fix it

  1. Test it yourself. Type a nonsense address after your domain, such as /this-page-does-not-exist-12345. Open the developer tools, look at the network panel and find the status of the main request. It should be 404.
  2. Find where the status is set. In WordPress, a theme’s 404 template normally returns the correct code, so a plugin or a redirect rule is the likely culprit. On a custom or static site, check the server’s error document setting.
  3. Stop redirecting everything to the home page. Remove catch-all redirects. Redirect only the specific old addresses that have a meaningful new home.
  4. Make the 404 page helpful. It should return the 404 status, say plainly that the page does not exist and offer a search, a menu and a link to the home page; see the guide to custom 404 pages.
  5. Use 410 when a page is gone for good, if you want search engines to drop it faster; the article on 410 Gone and 404 Not Found explains the difference.
  6. Run the check again. The warning should be gone.

The page on HTTP status codes for SEO lists the codes that matter and what each tells a search engine.

A note on JavaScript sites

Sites built as single-page applications are especially prone to soft 404s. The server sends the same file for every address, and the script in the browser decides what to show. If the script displays “page not found” but the server has already answered 200, the crawler sees a valid page. The fix is to make the server aware of which addresses exist, or to have the application ask for a real 404 response where possible. If you run such a site and are unsure, talk to the developer and show them the finding with the nonsense address test.

What about pages that are really gone?

Once the server tells the truth, you can decide what each old address should do. Pages that moved deserve a redirect to the new location. Pages that were removed deliberately with no replacement can answer 404, or 410 if you want to be explicit. Pages that were thin and are now merged into a better page should redirect to that page. The decision for each should be made on the question: what would a visitor who arrives at this old address want to find? If there is a good answer, redirect to it, and if there is none, show an honest error page.

Watching Search Console afterwards

After the fix, look at the page indexing report in Search Console over the following weeks. The soft 404 entries should shrink as Google crawls the old addresses and receives the correct status. This takes time, because Google does not revisit every address quickly. If entries remain after a month, test a few of them directly in your browser: if one still returns 200, there may be a second rule or a cache that is still serving the old behaviour.

Why search engines punish pretending

Search engines learned long ago that many sites show a friendly error message and still answer 200, so they try to detect soft 404s on their own. But detection is guesswork and it is slower than a clear signal from your server. A correct 404 status is an unambiguous message that costs you nothing to send. Giving the right answer saves crawling effort for both sides and keeps the reports you rely on clean, so that real problems are easier to see among them.

A worked example

A regional estate agent’s site shows the warning: missing pages return 200 OK instead of 404. The owner types a random address after the domain and sees a friendly “Sorry, we could not find that page” message. In the browser’s network panel the status is 200. The agency had set a rule that sends every unknown address to a search page. It looks helpful, but it tells Google that thousands of addresses exist. The agency removes the catch-all rule, keeps the specific redirects for 30 old listings, and makes the search page return the 404 status when it finds no result for an address. A new check shows no warning, and over the following weeks Search Console’s list of soft 404 pages shrinks.

To test your own server, check your website with Site AI Audit. The check needs a free account; the plans unlock the full report.

Related reading

The bottom line

A missing page should say so, with a 404 status. If your server answers 200 for addresses that do not exist, fix the 404 template or remove the catch-all redirect, and run the audit again to confirm that the server now tells the truth.

DUK

How can I test for a soft 404 myself?

Open an address on your domain that cannot exist and check the status code in your browser’s developer tools. It should be 404.

Is a custom 404 page a problem?

No, as long as it returns the 404 status. A friendly page with the wrong status is the typical soft 404.

Should I redirect deleted pages to the home page?

Not by default. Redirect to a relevant page when one exists. Otherwise let the old address return 404 or 410.

Does a soft 404 affect my rankings?

Mostly indirectly. It wastes crawling and can fill the index with empty pages, which makes your real pages harder to evaluate.

Why is this a warning and not critical?

It does not break the site for visitors, but it affects how search engines treat the site, so it is worth fixing soon.

#Indexing#Technical SEO#Troubleshooting
Patikrinkite savo svetainę.Ar jūsų svetainė apsaugota nuo įsilaužimo?
Tikrinti svetainę

Daugiau iš blogo

Visi straipsniai →
Internet Solutions

Daugiau iš mūsų komandos

Sukūrė Internet Solutions. Išbandykite ir kitus mūsų produktus — kiekvienas sutaupo laiko vis kitaip.

internet-solutions.net ↗